What if Victoria Woodhull Won The 1872 Presidential Election?This alternative history series plays out the constitutional crisis![]() ![]() Victoria Woodhull is the first woman to run for president. She did so in 1872, before women had the right to vote. Nobody believed that she had a chance in hell of winning. After all, she couldn’t cast a ballot for herself; would anyone actually take her seriously? We don’t know how many people voted for her. The popular vote for the 1872 election isn’t immediately available partly because her party did not print ballots everywhere. Nobody cast an electoral vote for her. Though they could have. The Electoral College is the method in which the president of the United States is chosen. Even though we don’t know how many popular votes she garnered, the lack of electoral college votes is part of the public record. How could electors have voted for her? Well, Horace Greeley, the Liberal Republican nominee for president, passed away before the electoral college votes were cast. This left the electors free to vote for whoever they wanted. Most of them went with the incumbent, President Ulysses Grant. But what if they didn’t? Electors back then were not required to cast their votes for the candidate their state had chosen. They could have voted for anyone in the country. To either make a statement or laugh at someone’s expense. Don’t believe that happened. One town in Kansas saw it happen. And it helped to set a precedent for many other things that were to come. That’s the same fate that could have met Victoria Woodhull, though on a grander scale. Not only would she have been the first woman elected to office, but she would also have been the first woman to hold the office of the president. This would have been unheard of at the time. The controversy would have overwhelmed the country. So many questions would be asked about Woodhull’s ability actually to deliver results. How do we end up with Woodhull as president of the United States? Believe it or not, a prank. As mentioned, some men used their power to torment women and prove that they belonged at home, not in the workforce. They wanted to ensure the status quo remained in place; it was what they were most comfortable with. To wit, in 1887, some men in Argonia, Kansas, nominated Salter to be mayor. They reasoned that once she lost, all women would be humiliated and discouraged from trying again. What they hadn’t counted on was Salter winning. Some historians believe that her victory was due, at least in part, to her father being the town's first-ever mayor. Another reason was that many of her friends switched their allegiance to her once it was revealed that Salter was a candidate. In those days, it was a blind ballot, so she didn’t even know that she was a contender until election day. When she did find out, she pledged to serve. She won by a huge margin. In this scenario, Victoria Woodhull would have gone through something similar. The electors who were supposed to be granted to Horace Greeley were freed to cast their votes for whomever they chose upon his death. This group of men might have found it funny to cast their votes for a woman, knowing there was no way she could win. Ulysses S. Grant, the incumbent, was slated to win in a landslide. But defections happened on his end too. During this period, electors were not sworn to cast their votes for the candidate who won their state’s popular vote. They could cast their vote for whomever they chose. A group hears about the plan to trick Woodhull into thinking that she has become President of the United States and decides to throw in on the prank. Once everyone had cast their votes, something stunning happened. Instead of Woodhull winning the Electoral College vote, the vote resulted in a tie between her and Grant. A situation like this would send the election to the House of Representatives, allowing that body of Congress to select the president. Once the election is in the hands of the House of Representatives, most believe it is a foregone conclusion that Grant will be elected president. After all, the suffrage movement is treated as nothing more than a joke. Women are not allowed to vote, let alone hold office, during this time. In a stunning turn, Grant and Woodhull each received 18 votes in the initial round, with the Kansas reps debating whom to support. Everyone waits with bated breath. It is announced that Kansas is voting for Woodhull. Grant and his team are shocked. They thought they had the election all wrapped up. He vows to fight the results, saying in a letter to the press that a woman cannot be president by law and that the House got it wrong. Over in the Senate, a measure was passed electing Ulysses S. Grant as Vice President of the United States. It passed with a unanimous vote. Most senators revealed they voted for the president to take the VP position because they did not want Frederick Douglass in the role, especially with Woodhull taking the White House. But how did he end up on that ballot? Henry Wilson went to the Senate floor and declined the Vice Presidency under Woodhull, suggesting that Grant was the better man for the role. His logic was that Woodhull would be removed and his former boss would end up in a second term. This further infuriates the current president and adds to his humiliation. Grant and his team brew up an argument that Woodhull is not eligible to be president. They argue that the Constitution requires the role to be filled by a man. They also argue that the electors acted in bad faith by switching their votes from Grant to the president-elect. Another member of Grant’s legal team points out that Woodhull is not even old enough to take office. She would be 34 on Inauguration Day; the Constitution specifically says the President must be at least 35 years old. When Woodhull gets wind of her VP’s plans, she and her team begin cobbling together her counterargument. It hinges on the separation of powers and holds that the court, even the highest court in the land, lacks authority to override the House of Representatives when it is performing its constitutional duty to elect the President. With the age argument, her legal team would argue that it was a nonissue. She’d be turning the appropriate age in less than seven months from being sworn in as POTUS. They would also remark that Grant’s main argument is that she’s a female rather than the age factor, which suggests they’re grasping at straws to overturn the will of Congress. As the country learns that a new president has been elected, there is shock that a woman will be taking the White House. Some people are concerned that Woodhull is not ready to take on such an important role. Others are furious that a woman is assuming the role. They believe that a lady’s place is in the home, taking care of her children and husband.
History
Politics
Gender
Political Parties
![]() Written by
6 Followers
Following 9
Ed is a true crime and history writer. He is known as the publisher of Crimebeat.
|

























