Why The Internet Sided With Kelly Clarkson in The Brooklyn Store Drama

The beloved singer isn't known for starting controversy
avatar
Posted on Oct 14, 2026 by
Ed Anderson
Business,   Social Media,   Celebrities,   News
  in Zone  Business Talk
4 mins read 
Kelly Clarkson's feud with Art of Play is not one sided
Image by Edward Anderson

When Kelly Clarkson ended her talk show, many people thought she would disappear from the spotlight for a while. Even though she launched a new single in the series finale of her show. And she was scheduled to be in the newest season of The Voice.

In their defense, Clarkson is not a celebrity that thrives on publicity. Rather, she moves in secret and only reveals projects when she needs to market them. Outside of that, people knew very little about her private life.

So when she took to social media and blasted a Brooklyn shop, the world paid attention.

The first American Idol winner claimed that she went into the shop to buy a couple of things. She inquired about a clock that was on the wall. She alleged that the clerk looked at her and decided that she could not afford it.

He offered to find her something more affordable. In her words, he was rude to her, and she left without making a purchase at all.

This could have been it. If the owner of Art of Play apologized for her experience and explained that the clock on the wall was not for sale for whatever reason, this controversy could have blown over. Maybe if the store had offered to speak to Clarkson about her experience, things would have been smoother.

But no, that is not the route that the store went. They tried to do everything in their power to make themselves a member of the public, to play the victim in a high-stakes feud that was of their own making.
. . .

Rather than take a sensible approach to the incident, the owner of Art of Play went on social media and blasted Clarkson. He claimed that she was overblowing the incident and that his store clerk did nothing wrong.

He went on to allege that Clarkson was a privileged celebrity who couldn't take no for an answer. The clock that she had inquired about was not for sale, even though there was a price tag attached to it.

Things were calm, and his store clerk followed policy. It was a normal day.

When Clarkson saw the defense post, she made a post of her own. In hers, she countered everything they said and posted pictures to prove her point. There was nothing normal about the way she was treated, and being rude is never the answer.

Once again Art of Play doubled down on their stance. Though, they did give a bit more explanation about the clock. It is allegedly made by a reclusive artist who takes years to finish projects.

But the best part of their defense was the release of the tapes. The video actually proved everything that Clarkson had said and made them look like whiny babies.

Did the owner of Art of Play know that his team was rude? Probably. Nearly everyone has encountered rude store clerks. And given his response to the controversy, it stands to reason that the Clarkson situation is normal for them.

Is that the reason why the internet took Kelly Clarkson's side?

. . .

It is part of the reason. Rude clerks are a dime a dozen. Stories abound about dealing with someone who treated them poorly, someone who judged them before knowing their story.

Clarkson's brand has always been that she is one of us. Yes, she does glamorous things like going to the Grammys or other award events. But at her core, she is one of the people. That's why we love her.

Also, Clarkson isn't known for getting involved in public drama. Some of her contemporaries may enjoy feuding with other public figures, but she prefers a much lower profile.

Further proof that Clarkson doesn't do drama is that she had an alleged rival on her talk show. In 2020, Carrie Underwood appeared virtually, and they had a great chat. And during her infamous Kellyoke segments, she sang a great deal of songs by the other woman.

Kelly Clarkson doesn't do drama.

That's why when she made those posts complaining about the treatment she received, most people took to her side. There were some who wanted to hear from the store.

And once they did, everyone moved to Clarkson's side. Because she did not exaggerate the situation, she did not make up an excuse for her behavior.

And Art of Play's actions after the controversy really reinforced the misogyny that came with their defense. They raised the price of the clock from $15,000 to $15 million. Which makes no sense for an item that allegedly wasn't for sale.

Those who expected Clarkson to disappear after the end of her talk show had another thing coming. Not only is she still recording music, but she also has a reality competition show. But she knows how to use social media to her advantage. Especially when she's wronged.

Business
Social Media
Celebrities
News
Comment
React
Play
Menu
avatar
Written by
6 Followers
Following 9
Ed is a true crime and history writer. He is known as the publisher of Crimebeat.