What if SCOTUS Sided With Victoria Woodhull's Electoral Win?

Part 2 explores the legal arguments for and against the election
avatar
Posted on Oct 21, 2026 by
Ed Anderson
Politics,   Supreme Court,   Fiction,   Careers
  in Zone  Pieces of History
4 mins read 
Photo by Cole Miller on Unsplash

President Ulysses S. Grant and his lawyers were furious over President-Elect Victoria Woodhull and her transition team beginning the work of moving the power from him to her. He vowed to not allow her to take office

He and his legal team began crafting an argument to the Supreme Court. Their main argument centered on Woodhull’s gender and the fact that women were not allowed to vote. Since women could not cast votes, certainly that meant that they should not be able to hold office. Especially not the presidency. They also noted that her election was unconstitutional because of her age.

Grant and his legal team were all convinced that SCOTUS would hear their argument and congratulate them on being legal geniuses. And then they would install Grant for his second term, righting the wrong done by the House of Representatives.

Yes, they legally argued misogyny.

Grant and his team were convinced that this was exactly the right argument to make. In their view, nothing Woodhull or her team could say would change the minds of the justices. Nobody wanted to see a woman in the role of president.

They also argued that all of the electoral college votes that Horace Greeley would have won should have been given to him. Why? Because he wanted them and he was already POTUS. There would be no legal reasoning, he just believed they were owed to him automatically.

He instructed his team to gauge the temperature of the highest court. While Grant believed this case should be a slam dunk for him, he needed it to be a unanimous decision. All nine justices needed to back him in using the court to swing the election back to him.

But was the argument against Woodhull strong enough?


Victoria Woodhull and her team were also preparing arguments for the Supreme Court. Their argument centered around the fact that the justices didn’t have a right or the authority to override an election decided by the House of Representatives. The separation of powers dictated that in the event that no candidate received enough electoral college votes then it was the House’s duty to elect the President. Which they did and it was legal.

They also countered that the age argument was null and void. It was only in the legal briefs to give the justices something to hang their hats on when they tried to rip the presidency away from the person who truly won it. The House knew her age when they voted for her and none of the laws prevented her from running with everyone understanding that she would be 34 until just under seven months after she was inaugurated.

Going further, they argued that if Woodhull wasn’t allowed to take office, a whole new election would need to be held. Horace Greeley died and Grant was elected vice president but would be unable to assume the presidency since he wasn’t sworn in.

In a bold move, Woodhull and her team wouldn’t just play this argument in front of the justices. They would take it to the press, particularly the tabloids, and play out the fight with Grant there.

Not only would they allege that he was targeting Woodhull simply because she was a woman but they would hint at other scandals. His vice president was connected to the Union Pacific Railroad scandal that was beginning to come to light, where a dummy corporation was set up to funnel money to members of Congress.

They also would tie him to the so-called “Black Friday” scandal. Woodhull and company would allege that even if Grant wasn’t directly involved, the bad actors were close enough to him that he would have known what was going on.

It was enough for her to win.


Inside the Supreme Court building, the justices debated whether or not to even take up Grant’s case. Aides worked overtime to bring each justice case law to help them strengthen their arguments or counter someone else’s.

The feeling inside the building was that this was a constitutional crisis but a decision from the court either way would only deepen the divide. No decision from the court would set a precedent that they would not interfere in a case, but that was just as dangerous in a circumstance where someone was trying to overthrow the government.

It was a no-win situation.

Salmon Chase argued that allowing the House’s vote to stand would open the country up to a larger debate about whether women should be allowed to vote or not. It would also destroy the family unit, as it would embolden women to join the workforce.

Arguing against him was Nathan Clifford. His argument was that a Supreme Court vote in any direction would place the court higher than the Executive and Legislative branches, which would cause an even worse crisis than what was being experienced.

He also noted that it was a political question, not a legal one.

Chase took that last argument and decided that the Supreme Court could not decide the election of 1872. Any questions about its constitutionality would be left for debate. It was not their job to decide if a woman could or should be president, that was for Congress and the voters.

As for the age requirement, not only would Woodhull be 35 during her first term in office but Congress and her party knew that she was only 34. Given that it did not bother either of those organizations, the court could not step in. And they noted that Grant’s main argument was about gender and not age. It could be assumed that he wasn’t worried about it, rather he was grasping at straws to keep the presidency.

With that, the justices assumed the worst was over. But a war was growing between the president-elect and the vice president-elect.

Politics
Supreme Court
Fiction
Careers
Comment
React
Play
Menu
avatar
Written by
6 Followers
Following 9
Ed is a true crime and history writer. He is known as the publisher of Crimebeat.