I've been searching for a hardware-based alternative to large, heavy, and clunky tube amps. I've tried many software-only products and found some that come close. While some software only alternatives some close for some sounds, none really get me all the way.
The Boss GT1000 has been around for many years. It is Boss's flagship product, which does amp emulations, speaker emulations, and contains almost all of Boss's pedals.
Boss recently released version 4, which adds some newer modern amps that sound, well, pretty convincing. One thing I've always liked about the Boss GT1000 is that it has a pedal that can be used to manipulate almost anything, such as volume, wah, reverb, EQ, etc.
But here are my questions: Is that the best tube amp alternative? Is it worth the money? Can it really sound like a tube amp when recorded?
Modlers vs tube amps
Since so many people are trying to model a tube amp, logic says that tube amps must be what everyone really wants. But why?
Well, that's a little more complicated. First off, modelers offer a far more flexible sound, a much lighter carrying load, and a much smaller footprint on the stage or in the studio. Modelers typically offer built-in effects, which tube amps, in general, do not. And lastly, modelers are usually less expensive than a tube amp.
I myself have had many tube amps and several modelers. Overall, I'm far less satisfied with modelers. They just don't give me the singing sounds that a tube amp can. Tubes break up in a special way that is, apparently, very difficult to mimic.
In the studio, a modeler can be plugged directly into the mixing board or DAW interface. That means no microphone and no external foot pedals. Simpler often means less complicated and faster to set up.
What about playing live?
For live venues, we're seeing more and more that guitar players are using modelers with a separate feed into their in-ear monitors. That means they can save their ears from fatigue and have far less floor space eaten up by big amps.
But here's a drawback: Amps give us the ability to get natural feedback, which can be used as a sound of its own or to just get much better sustaining of notes.
It's also, in my opinion, easier to reach an amp knobn to change something than to bend over the floor and start playing with a 4-inch or more display and known. Modelers are seldom straightforward about changing things. And while a modeler almost always has a memory to save those special tones we find, because of environmental differences between venues, those sounds need to be tweaked.
What's the Answer
Is the Boss GT1000 then an answer? Yes and no. It has some great sounds. And while modelers often do a pretty good job on clean tones, they often do only an OK job on high-gain sounds. I feel that distorted sounds are a little more subjective. There are so many levels and types of distortion that it's hard to be unbiased. For a country play, modeler A might be perfect. But for a Blues player, no, not at all. For a metal band, modeler B might be perfect, whereas it would be terrible for country.
Since there are so many types of music, so many types of bands, and so many guitar players with their own idea of what's perfect, no one can definitely state that any product is perfect for everyone and in all circumstances.
For the reasons above, I keep coming back to the tube amp being the perfect answer. If it has the basic clean, distorted, and overdrive sounds I like, I can add effects with pedals. In general, a pedal can offer a larger variety of effects. If you don't like it, use a different pedal. If you don't like the modeler's effects, you're stuck and may end up adding pedals anyway!
And, with modelers always being enhanced and upgraded, and newer models coming out all the time, it's getting very messy. One of the most difficult things I find is trying to decide what to buy. Since music stores don't have every conceivable amp, pedal, and modeler. So, doing an A/B test between the products you think might be good is almost impossible. And, the music store is not the typical venue in which a band might play.
The bottom line is that even if you find something in a music store you think might be perfect, you might get is home and find it may not be.
I've been writing and performing music for decades, playing my guitar, and doing full-stack software development to feed my soul! I love learning new things but also realizing when something being new doesn't always make it better.